the last visible dog (intertext) wrote,
the last visible dog

Karamazblog: Book IV

Book I
Book II by marri
Book III by lidocafe

And now, Book IV, in which Alyosha has a number of encounters with sundry personages, some rather emotional, some, indeed, hysterical, and is left perplexed about the vagaries of the human condition (as are we).

Book IV opens with Alyosha (and a bunch of other monks) hanging about at the bedside of Fr Zosima, waiting for him to die. He doesn't. He gives a long speech, which is summarized many years later by Alyosha. There is a long digression, telling the story of a monkly visitor from another town who has a strange encounter with a Fr Ferapont.

Alyosha then goes to visit his father, and they have quite a civilized conversation (for once). On leaving, Alyosha kisses his father on the shoulder (wtf?), at which Karamazov pere exclaims "don't you expect to see me again?" Do we hear ominous music on the soundtrack??

Alyosha then goes to visit the Khokhlakovs, where pretty much everyone (Mrs K, Katerina and Lise) except him has some form of hysterics.

Oh, and I forgot that on the way to see them he intervenes with some boys throwing rocks and gets bitten in the finger by the one he was trying to rescue. (I'm not making this up).

Then he goes to visit one Capt Snegirev, whom Dmitri insulted by pulling his beard, and it turns out that the boy who bit Alyosha is Snegirev's son and bit Alyosha because he was Dmitri's brother (though how the son knew that is not explained...). Snegirev has a seriously weird wife and a clever but snippy daughter and another daughter who is one of those saintly cripples that turn up in novels of this period. Alyosha tries to give Snegirev 200 rubles, but Snegirev refuses it very melodramatically.

Okay. Despite the flippancy of the above summary, I actually found myself enjoying this section of the novel, and I think I might be getting the hang of it.

One motif/theme/idea or whatever that seems to be emerging is an exploration of aspects of "genuine" vs artifice, disguise, hidden motives, overly dramatic emotions. Alyosha is genuine. He may be good because he's innocent but he has honest emotions, he wants to do the right thing, he's not playing a role. Almost everyone else is, and one of Alyosha's difficulties, and ours along with him, is in sorting out who's faking and who isn't. Look at the way Katerina behaves - everyone can tell that she's putting "it" on, except we don't really know what she's doing or why. Snegirev self-consciously flings the 200 rubles in Alyosha's face, and Alyosha realizes (this happens in the next book, but I need to mention it here) that he was, to a certain extent playing a role. I'm pretty sure Father Zosima is genuine, and the bit about Fr Ferapont suggests to me a contrast between real and false piety. Fr Ferapont is ostentatiously ascetic and "everybody" says how pious and saintly he is, except it's clear that the narrator, or the author is making us question that. Another thing to note from the beginning of the next book is the way that Mrs K keeps saying "this is serious" as if all the emo in the previous chapter wasn't.

Another thing: of course, I'm all about the metafiction, but I can't help noticing and being really intrigued by the way that so much of the narrative is "framed" - very self-consciously narrative - something is described the way Alyosha remembers it years later, or how someone "told" the narrator. Marri - notice in the first chapter of Book V, how Alyosha tells Lise all about his encounter with Snegirev.

The book begins with Zosima giving a lesson on how we must "love God's people" and, above all, not be proud. We are all responsible for one another, and none of us should consider ourself better than anyone else. There but for the grace of god, and all that. Clearly, the incident with Snegirev is meant to drive that point home; indeed it could be argued that all Alyosha's curious encounters with peculiar people are so intended.
Tags: karamazblog

  • The Weakness in Me

    Robinson's death has hit me hard. Also, the general feeling of doglessness. I haven't been without a dog, except for when on holiday, for eighteen…

  • Silly old dog

    Ate ten prawn shells last night. Of course, that means that stupid owner left them somewhere where dog could get them (and ate 10 spot prawns all by…

  • You know your dog is old when...

    You have to drive him (two and a half blocks) to the dog park. You are ecstatic when you realize that he's still breathing, though deeply asleep. You…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 1 comment